who would make a better Cat?

[Vivian]

I will be back with the second video in a few minutes.



who is better?
I like the second one best.

Peace,Vivian

[M.]

1st one sounds much better to me... almost original

...don't like this Tom Fry...

[Vivian]

well, I agree I like the singing of Darren Coggin better. but I think as far as physical appearances, I think Tom Fry is better. now I didn't see Darren's acting, but I like Tom.s acting in this clip. Maybe both could be used.

Peace,Vivian

[Affy]

I like Tome Fry - his acting is good and his singing is good too.

His voice is pretty good when talking but when he sings it sounds like hes got a marsh-mellow stuck in his throat maybe if he removed it he would be the overall winner coz darren coggan has the better Cat Steven Singing voice.

Hope that made sense LOL

[monabonejakoff]

No he doesn't but what the heck - he is good.

[Vivian]

okay, we agree that Tom Fry has the better look and Darren Coggen has the better voice, we can use both of them.

peace,Vivian

[Monty Python]

I saw Darren Coggan's show here in Melbourne when it was called Moonshadow... he sounds a lot like Cat. That other guy looks a bit similar, and has got some mannerisms right, but not the sound.

[JaneB]

I listened to them without watching them, and I'm with Monika on this one. I like the first one very much; I didn't care for the second one at all.

[ilovemycat]

really - I watched just a bit of each and thought Tom Fry sounded much more like Cat.

[blossom]

:)When push comes to shove I agree with Ilovemycat....

[Deleted]

I missed Alun Davies ;-)

[Vivian]

so the next question would be, who would make a good Alun Davies?

Peace,Vivian